Blacklist Fades to Gray, Then Disappears

 

Like that illusive Cheshire Cat in Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland that appears and disappears at will, the threatened G-20 "blacklist" of  allegedly disreputable tax havens seems suddenly to have evaporated into the murky international fog.

You will recall that at a scheduled April 2nd "G-20" London meeting of major nations, dominated by high tax welfare states, it was expected the group would issue a new anti-tax haven blacklist, with Germany and France in the lead pushing for condemnation of even Switzerland, the cleanest and most respected of all offshore financial centers.

What Tax Bullies Really Want

In truth, financial cleanliness has never been the true objective of the high tax nations that make a habit of bullying low tax jurisdictions.

As Veronique de Rugy notes in the current issue of Reason magazine: In the part of high tax nations, "bank secrecy laws have long been seen as an obstacle to tax enforcement." As she says, supposedly by setting up "safe havens" for dollars, pounds, and euros, bank secrecy laws get in the way of these governments "forcing their high income tax rates down its taxpayers' throats."

The only way to fix this problem, the high tax welfare states argue, is for all nations to implement an automatic and unlimited exchange of information about nonresident investment. So-called tax havens, goes this line of thinking, should collect private financial data on foreigners and turn that information over to the appropriate governments.

Decade of Offshore Improvements

Most offshore financial centers, (as they now prefer to be called), have been shaken by the sudden intensification of pressure, especially after they have worked hard adapting to international demands for more transparency during the past decade.

The latest crackdown has been fueled by alleged tax evasion scandals in Liechtenstein and Switzerland in last year, the election of an avowed enemy of tax havens as U.S. president and the near collapse of the global banking system -- which the more radical anti-tax haven critics brazenly blamed on tax havens.
Jean-Claude Juncker (left), Luxembourg's Finance Minister responded on that point by saying: "Imagine for a moment that Switzerland, Austria and Luxembourg did not have banking secrecy six months or a year ago. Do you really think that the financial crisis would be any less serious? There is no link between banking secrecy and the global economic crisis."

American Hypocrisy

The U.K. Channel Islands (Jersey, Guernsey) ten years ago adopted legislation making foreign tax evasion a crime; other U.K. offshore centers (Cayman Islands, Bermuda, British Virgin Islands) followed suit shortly thereafter.

 

  
Large countries like the United States have yet to take similar steps, no doubt because the substantial tax free deposits from foreigners in U.S. banks provide essential funding for America's trillion dollar budget deficits.

Expert observers, including the International Monetary Fund, have regularly acknowledged U.K. offshore territories' transparency and supervision as amongst the toughest in the global finance industry.

The reputation of the offshore centers like Switzerland and the U.K. Crown Dependencies (Isle of Man, Channel Islands) and U.K. overseas territories, such as Bermuda and Cayman for probity, professional skills and financial sophistication enables them to attract capital from around the world. Such offshore capital is injected into U.K., Europe and the U.S. banking and securities markets, creating crucial connections with such centers.

Ten Years of Phony Blacklists

For more than a decade high tax nations have condemned as aiding and abetting massive tax evasion, any offshore jurisdiction that has low taxes, respects financial privacy and guarantees bank secrecy.

These anti-tax haven, anti-financial privacy campaigns have been spearheaded by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), a paid, pro-tax mouthpiece for the major nations. The OECD invented the blacklist and has  used it skillfully as a public relations ploy to smear tax havens.

Capitulation

Indeed, the OECD had at the ready its latest blacklist for the G-20 London meeting when an unexpected thing happened. Many of the countries that were destined to be smeared in the list agreed in the future to apply OECD standards allowing exchange of tax information among all nations.

Now the pursuit of specific tax evaders by foreign countries supposedly will be made easier by greater co-operation from Switzerland, Austria, Luxembourg, Belgium, Hong Kong, Singapore, Liechtenstein, Andorra and Monaco, among others. All announced last week their agreement to broader but limited tax information exchange.

Never Enough
But don't count on the tax collectors to stop now. German Finance Minister Peer Steinbrueck (left) has told Der Spiegel that he wants countries like Switzerland to reveal  the names of all their account holders "even when there's no concrete suspicion of tax evasion."

 

Nevertheless, Steinbrueck, one of the most caustic anti-tax haven critic, said on Friday he did not think G-20 leaders meeting in London next month now would come up with a blacklist of tax havens. "As far as I see, there will be no such list at the London meeting."

German Chancellor Angela Merkel said she could not imagine any country that accepted OECD standards for exchanging tax information would be on a blacklist, but she gloated that the mere talk of this "virtual list" had already had "positive" effects.

International Blackmail

So "positive" that the much herald G-20 "blacklist" suddenly has faded into momentary obscurity, no doubt to be kept in reserve for a re-appearance in the next high tax onslaught against low tax jurisdictions which, in my opinion, is just a matter of time.

But I suggest that we call all these phony campaigns what they really are -- not a blacklist, but blackmail.

The Sovereign Society is a recognized voice in the complex offshore world.  Join the Sovereign Society and keep informed.